Malaysians Regretting Singapore Citizenship: An Unforgettable Journey
Introduction
Malaysia and Singapore, two neighboring countries with a complex relationship, are often discussed in the context of citizenship and migration. Many Malaysians have crossed the border for various reasons, from education to employment, only to find that obtaining Singapore citizenship might not be the best decision in the long run. This article discusses the experiences and regrets of those who have moved to Singapore and eventually felt the need to return to their roots in Malaysia.
Personal Experiences and Insights
My story began in JB, born and raised in Johor Baru before migrating to Singapore. My life in Singapore was memorable, from completing national service with the Singapore Armed Forces (SAF) to securing scholarships and working as a civil servant for 13 years. The experience was enriching, but the desire to explore life elsewhere grew over time.
After nine years of studying abroad, I decided to seek new opportunities in a land I perceived as a socialist democracy. My ideal destination was far from the authoritarian rule I admired in Singapore, where egalitarian values, a multiparty government, freedom of press, and the absence of capital punishment were paramount. This idealistic vision guided my decision to leave Singapore and move to a place where the cost of living was high but where the social benefits were plentiful.
Challenges and Regrets
The decision to adopt Singapore citizenship was fraught with challenges. While Singapore and Malaysia share good diplomatic relations, the challenges of adjusting to life in a country with a very different culture and lifestyle were significant. Frequenting multiple countries without the allowance of dual citizenship can make life complex, especially for those who move frequently.
One recurring theme is the issue of multiple citizenship. Many Malaysians who have gained PR (Permanent Resident) status or even citizenship in Singapore felt demoralized and unfulfilled, finding it difficult to invest in the country they once called home. They eventually gave up their citizenship in their late 40s, ready to reap the benefits of their hard work in Malaysia.
Benefits of Retaining Malaysian Citizenship
Malaysians who have settled down in Malaysia with families often retain their Malaysian citizenship, knowing that they have a support network where they can retire. The CPF (Central Provident Fund) system in Singapore offers significant benefits, but it requires individuals to commit to the country financially. The ease of living in Malaysia, with its myriad of characteristics like lower taxes and healthcare costs, makes it an attractive option for expatriates.
My children, born and holding Malaysian citizenship, have a future filled with choice. At 18, they are free to make their own decisions, including the option to ‘return home’ if they wish to. The support and protection offered by Malaysian citizenship are invaluable, especially for those who have settled in a different country.
Conclusion
For many Malaysians, the decision to obtain Singapore citizenship can be a regrettable one. The complexities of life in a different country, combined with the desire to remain connected to their roots, often lead to difficult choices. While Singapore offers many benefits, it is a 'do or die' situation for those who choose to live and work there. Choosing to retain Malaysian citizenship allows individuals the flexibility to navigate life with ease, enjoying the benefits of their home country while making wise life choices.